42, Isanov str., 720017, Bishkek, Kyrgyz Republic
Ministry of Transport and Communications of the Kyrgyz Republic
Project Implementation Unit of the Asian Development Bank
Loan No. 3730- KGZ (SF)/ Grant No. 0621- KGZ: Kyrgyz Republic:
CAREC Corridors 1 and 3 Connector Road Project – Additional financing.
Selection of Road Safety Audit and Technology Consultants
CONTRACT AWARD INFORMATION
General information
CAREC Corridors 1 and 3 Connector Road Project – Additional Financing aims to help the Kyrgyz Republic in the implementation of the national road safety strategy and offers opportunities to demonstrate safety technologies for potential future use on the state road network. The CAREC Corridors 1 and 3 Connector Road Project – Additional Financing includes a road safety component. This component is envisaged to be implemented through three sub-outputs: (i) sub-output 1: development of a national road safety strategy, (ii) sub-output 2: road safety auditing introduced into the business process of the Ministry of Transport and Communications (MOTC), and (iii) sub-output 3: the latest technology for safer transport services applied along the project roads.
The following 20 consulting firms submitted Expressions of Interest by the deadline:
|
No. |
Firm name |
|
|
Donghae Engineering & Consultants Co., Ltd. (Korea, Republic of) |
|
|
Joint venture between Holtec Consulting Private Limited (India) and Dhruv Consultancy Services Limited (India) |
|
|
Osmani & Company (Pvt.) Limited (Pakistan) in association with E.Gen Consultants Ltd. (Bangladesh) and KyrgyzGeoTech LLC (Kyrgyz Republic) |
|
|
Pricewaterhousecoopers Pvt. Ltd. (India) in association with PricewaterhouseCoopers Tax and Advisory, LLP (Kazakhstan) |
|
|
VisionRI Connexion Services Private Limited (India) in association with M A SOLUTIONS PVT LTD (India) |
|
|
Joint venture between ALTINOK CONSULTING ENGINEERING INC. (Turkey) and M50 Consulting Group LLP (Kazakhstan) |
|
|
Joint venture between BOTEK Bosphorus Technical Consulting Corp. (Turkey) and ARPA Consulting (Azerbaijan) |
|
|
CONTRANS AB (Sweden) |
|
|
EBP Schweiz AG (Switzerland) |
|
|
Joint venture between Egis International (France) and Egis Villes & Transports (France) |
|
|
Joint venture between FRED Engineering Srl (Italy) and IRD Engineering S.R.L. (Italy) in association with RAM Engineering Associates LLC (Kyrgyz Republic) |
|
|
Kocks Consult Gmbh (Germany) |
|
|
MC Mobility Consultants GmbH (Austria) |
|
|
Joint venture between NTU International A/S (Denmark) and IMC Worldwide Ltd. (United Kingdom) |
|
|
Renardet S.A. (Switzerland) in association with RAM Engineering Associates LLC (Kyrgyz Republic) |
|
|
Joint venture between Roughton International Ltd (United Kingdom) and Consulting Engineers Group Ltd (India) |
|
|
Joint venture between SGAPI S.R.L. (Italy) and Aarvee Associates Architects Engineers and Consultants Private Limited (India) |
|
|
Joint venture between Swedish National Road Consulting AB (Sweden) and Japan Overseas Consultants Co., Ltd. (Japan) in association with Central Asian Consulting Center (Kyrgyz Republic) |
|
|
TUMAS Turkish Engineering, Consulting and Contracting Co. (Turkey) |
|
|
Temelsu International Engineering Services Inc. (Turkey) |
Technical and financial proposals were received from the following firms:
Results of the technical evaluation:
|
No. |
Firm name |
Technical score |
|
|
NTU International A/S (Denmark) with IMC Worldwide Ltd.(United Kingdom) as JV Partner; |
760,00 |
|
|
JV MC Mobility Consultants GmbH (Austria) Partner of NAST Consultants (Austria) and sub-consultants of TBSC Consulting (Georgia) and United Group (Kyrgyz Republic); |
863,75 |
|
|
FRED Engineering Srl (Italy) with IRD Engineering S.R.L. (Italy) as JV Partner, and RAM Engineering Associates LLC (Kyrgyz Republic) as Sub-Consultant; |
785,38 |
|
|
Renardet S.A. (Swizerland) and RAM Engineering Associates LLC (Kyrgyz Republic) as Sub-Consultant |
693,50 |
|
|
Kocks Consult Gmbh (Germany) |
753,25 |
|
|
Swedish National Road Consulting AB (Sweden) with Japan Overseas Consultants Co., Ltd. (Japan) as JV Partner, and Central Asian Consulting Center (Kyrgyz Republic) as Sub-Consultant. |
829,50 |
As a result of the evaluation, the ranking was as follows:
|
Consulting Entity |
Technical Evaluation |
Financial Evaluation |
Combined Score |
Final Ranking |
|||||
|
Technical Score |
Technical Points |
Rank |
Evaluated Total Price (ETP) |
Financial Score |
Financial Points |
Rank |
|||
|
A |
B |
|
C |
D |
E |
|
F = B + E |
||
|
NTU International A/S, with IMC Worldwide Ltd. as JV Partner |
760,00 |
684,00 |
4 |
1 590 605,00 |
865,39 |
86,54 |
3 |
770,54 |
5 |
|
FRED Engineering Srl with IRD Engineering S.R.L. as JV Partner, and RAM Engineering Associates LLC as Sub-Consultant |
785,38 |
706,84 |
3 |
1 521 600,00 |
904,64 |
90,46 |
2 |
797,31 |
3 |
|
Kocks Consult Gmbh |
753,25 |
677,93 |
5 |
1 376 500,00 |
1 000,00 |
100,00 |
1 |
777,93 |
4 |
|
JV MC Mobility Consultants GmbH (Austria) Partner of NAST Consultants (Austria) and sub-consultants of TBSC Consulting (Georgia) and United Group (Kyrgyz Republic) |
863,75 |
777,38 |
1 |
1 657 433,20 |
830,50 |
83,05 |
5 |
860,43 |
1 |
|
Swedish National Road Consulting AB, with Japan Overseas Consultants Co., Ltd. as JV Partner, and Central Asian Consulting Center as Sub-Consultant |
829,50 |
746,55 |
2 |
1 646 549,00 |
835,99 |
83,60 |
4 |
830,15 |
2 |